A group of three happy customers in a New York City car dealership, giving thumbs up next to red and blue cars, with a saleswoman holding a tablet in the background, representing car hire.

Which days are cheapest to rent a car in New York City for 2025 trips?

In NYC, timing is everything. Compare midweek versus weekend collections, try different pick‑up times and check airpo...

2 min. Lesezeit

Quick Summary

  • Midweek collections often price more gently than peak Friday starts.
  • Airport counters can beat some city locations on busy weekends.
  • Small shifts in pick‑up or return times can change the total a lot.

Between Friday flight surges at JFK, weekend escapes to the Hudson Valley and game days in Queens, timing can nudge prices up or down. If you want the best value, the day and time you collect and return the vehicle can matter as much as the class you choose.

Start by checking prices for car rental at JFK across a couple of nearby days. In Hola Car Rentals, nudge the calendar forward or back 24 hours and watch totals shift. A Sunday afternoon to Tuesday morning window can occasionally price better than a Friday to Sunday weekend, while longer multi‑day bookings often reduce the average daily figure.

When do prices tend to dip

Patterns change with seasons and events, but many travellers see lower totals when avoiding Friday morning collections and late‑Sunday returns. If your schedule is flexible, try a weekday pick‑up in late morning or early afternoon and compare it with evening pick‑ups. Always benchmark the airports against city locations to see which side wins on your dates.

Logistics also influence the choice. For a quick overview of access, see the JFK Rental Car Center page. If New Jersey fits your plans, check Newark airport pick‑ups which can outshine city rates on busy weekends. Brand‑loyal travellers can compare Enterprise rates at JFK alongside Hertz deals at JFK, and families can review family minivan rentals to secure seats and boot space.

How Hola Car Rentals helps you land a lower total

We make it easy to compare dates, counters and classes on the same page. Savings stack through clear pricing, No additional fees and save 60% guaranteed on selected offers, plus Free Cancellation up to 48 hours before pick‑up on eligible rates. If you are deciding between the three airports, our NYC airports rental guide summarises the pros and cons for city trips.

FAQs

  • Are weekends always cheaper? Not always. Event weekends and holidays tend to lift prices. Try a weekday start where possible.
  • Does pick‑up time matter? Yes. Midday collections can price differently to very early or very late pick‑ups.
  • Is Manhattan dearer than the airports? Often yes on peak dates. Use airport counters as a benchmark.
  • How far ahead should I book? For popular dates, aim a few weeks in advance to secure the best selection and value.
  • Are tolls included in the total? No. Tolls are separate. You can add toll options at checkout or pay by mail where available.

Test a few date combinations, compare airports and counters, and lock in the option that fits your calendar. Hola Car Rentals keeps the process fast and transparent for New York trips.